Three months ago, President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un were shaking hands, sharing short ribs and signing a vague — but exciting — roadmap for “peace and prosperity.” Now, things appear to be on the verge of falling apart.
On Aug. 24, the White House abruptly canceled Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s upcoming Pyongyang visit. Then, just days later, the US blocked a field study that would allow South Korean President Moon Jae-in to begin planning the $36 billion railway system he promised North Korea — a strategic incentive to keep Kim in good spirits. Much of Moon's plans to improve relations and the South Korean economy — including a re-opening of the Kaesong Industrial Complex and the inter-Korean train system — would violate the UN sanctions that the US is trying to enforce against North Korea.
Trump blamed the sputtering halt to talks on another set of unmet promises: “I feel we are not making sufficient progress with respect to the denuclearization of the Korean peninsula,” he tweeted on Aug. 25. “Additionally, because of our much tougher trading stance with China, I do not believe they are helping with the process of denuclearization as they once were.”
It’s a major blow to Moon’s hopes for a new era. But he’s still shooting for progress — Moon plans to meet Kim in Pyongyang sometime this month, and a special envoy is expected to firm the details tomorrow. But even so, one has to wonder how far things can truly progress without Trump’s support — and even worse, whether renewed relations will sour.
“The Moon administration is quite enthusiastic to do more with the North, but it’s not like they have much choice in the matter,” said Peter Ward, a Seoul-based columnist at NK News and a former researcher at the Asan Institute for Policy Studies. “If the White House continues to believe that not much can continue before denuclearization, then South Korea can’t accomplish much.”
North Korea and the United States are in the throes of a disagreement they’ve always had: What comes first — denuclearization or an end to the Korean War?
In short, it’s a trust issue: North Korea has been accused of continuing its nuclear program, and the White House is committed to choking the country with economic sanctions until it’s completely shuttered. But from North Korea’s perspective, the United States has done very little to show its good faith: Since his meeting with Trump, Kim Jong-un has returned the remains of US soldiers, dismantled missile-testing facilities and reeled in some of the anti-American rhetoric. Meanwhile, the US hasn’t done much other than halt its joint military exercises with South Korea.
“If you add up these confidence-building measures, North Korea has done a lot more than the US has reciprocated — and we don’t know if the US is not making good on something it said it would do,” said Jenny Town, a research analyst at the Stimson Center and managing editor of the analysis site 38 North. “And none of [North Korea’s concessions] are reducing North Korea’s core nuclear capabilities, but they weren’t meant to. These are trust-building measures so that we can move forward. ... I think people just have really bad, unrealistic expectations of what North Korea is supposed to be doing after the Singapore summit.”
Technically, North Korea promised to “work toward complete denuclearization” at its summits with Trump and Moon — not give up their nuclear weapons outright.
“This was never the deal from the beginning, and North Korea was always transparent about that,” said C. Harrison Kim, an assistant professor at the University of Hawaii at Manoa who studies socialism in East Asia and North Korea. “We all knew from the beginning that abolishing nuclear weapons was not an immediate goal — that this is a long-term project.”
Other experts believe that North Korea will likely never give up its nuclear weapons — though that doesn’t mean they’ll always threaten to use them.
“The US is going to have to learn to live with a nuclear North Korea, and a nuclear North Korea doesn’t inherently have to be a great threat to the rest of the world,” Ward said. “At the end of it all, North Korea is probably still going to have nuclear weapons and there’s very little we can do about that — except starting a nuclear war, and that’s a terrible idea.”
Relations between the US and North Korea may be tense, but it’s really Moon who could lose the most. Much of the South Korean president’s first term banked on improved relations with the North, at first yielding him a sky-high, 88-percent approval rating.
But these days, the excitement of the summits have largely died down on the streets of Seoul. South Koreans are going on with their lives, largely returning their attention to the tough economy. Moon’s approval ratings have slid to roughly 55 percent.
Moon may be stuck in political gridlock if the US or North Korea doesn’t change its stance soon.
“It’s going to be a difficult discussion for Moon. He’s made some really bold commitments to North Korea that he can’t keep,” Town said. “The question really becomes, ‘Is he willing to violate sanctions to make good on North Korea?’ And if he isn’t, inter-Korean relations will start to stall as well.”
North Korea likely wants to broker a deal that lifts sanctions “so the South Koreans and Chinese can invest in them,” Ward said. But again, the problem lies partly in the United States’ desire to achieve denuclearization first.
“How can you force to them to denuclearize if you’ve already pumped the place with money? And how can you make them denuclearize without pumping the place with money?” Ward said. “There’s sort of this game of chicken going on.”
Nevertheless, it’s too soon to say all hopes are gone. Experts hope that the next inter-Korean summit will bring on a wave of good spirits, and hopefully pave the way for another meeting between Trump and Kim.
“Every diplomatic effort has its ups and downs, and we’re clearly in a downswing,” Town said. “But that doesn’t mean this is the end.”
Editor’s note: We’ve partnered with a video game company to let our readers put themselves in the shoes of someone who deals with nuclear weapons. Try the game for yourself at nucleardecisions.org.