There’s one number in the news quite a bit recently — 11 million.
It’s the estimated number of immigrants living in the U.S. illegally — and it’s the most cited statistic in the immigration reform debate. But how did we even get to that figure? Who are the 11 million? Is it even the best number to use?
It’s a number that Jeffrey Passel has tracked probably more than anyone else. He’s a senior demographer at the Pew Hispanic Center. To reach the 11 million figure, he crunched government data and used a formula.
“The total number of immigrants, minus the number of immigrants here legally, is the number here without authorization,” he said.
Sounds simple, but it’s not. In fact, 26 years ago, when Ronald Reagan signed an amnesty for 3 million immigrants, there was much disagreement over how to calculate the number. Many people argued there were three to four times that many immigrants without authorization living in the country.
Pew’s formula uses Labor Department survey data that includes workers’ country of origin to estimate the total number of immigrants in the country. It subtracts the number admitted legally based on federal immigration statistics. Then it makes some statistical adjustments to reach the 11 million estimate.
“Today, there’s a much broader agreement about how many people we’re talking about and about who we’re talking about,” Passel said.
So then, let’s accept that 11 million figure as the number of people here without documents. That’s more than the total population of Greece, by the way. But who are they?
Some of what the Passel has found is probably no surprise. About six million of the 11 million are Mexicans. Sixty percent are men. A majority live in large states like California, Texas, Illinois and New York.
But more than four million immigrants without legal status now live in the Midwest and the South — with states like Georgia and Oklahoma seeing this population rise fast. More of the U.S. now has a stake in the immigration debate.
“It’s part of, I think, the demographic underpinnings of what’s turned this into a national debate instead of a local debate,” Passel said.
There are also hundreds of thousands of Salvadorans, Guatemalans, Chinese, Koreans and Filipinos. Some entered legally, didn’t plan on staying — but did.
“Forty percent entered the country through a port of entry, and then just overstayed their visas,” said Ben Winograd, a former attorney at the American Immigration Council, based in Washington, D.C.
And if you look harder at the 11 million, another picture emerges — one of families. The majority of undocumented immigrants, both men and women, live with their families. So under one roof, there can be a mix of legal status: A dad without papers, a daughter who’s a citizen, an older brother who’s not.
Families like that of Gloria Mejia can show how complicated it can get. On a recent afternoon, she was picking her 8-year-old son Joaquin up from school in San Diego.
Mejia is undocumented, but her son is a citizen. She said being undocumented has hurt her children.
“It makes me sad that I can’t help them more,” she said.
Even Joaquin, her only child who’s a U.S. citizen, has been affected.
He wanted to join a soccer team. But the team would travel to tournaments outside California, and Mejia would need to help chaperone. But she’s afraid to travel, and risk deportation, so she told her son no.
“That example you’ve given is so perfect. That you can’t travel across states to participate in a soccer tournament,” said Michael Fix, a senior vice president of the Migration Policy Institute. “It may mean that a mother is less likely to go to a PTA conference.”
Fix says research shows children who are U.S. citizens — but whose parents are undocumented, in the shadows — are set back cognitively, socially and educationally.
So, when we think about the estimated 11 million people here illegally, Passel says it’s important to also think about the 4.5 million U.S. citizen children with undocumented parents.
“Instead of 11 million people we’re talking more about 16 million,” Passel said.
That’s a considerably larger number than the 11 million we so often hear, but Passel said it might be just as important.