Business, Economics and Jobs

New bus line serves Palestinian workers -- but not without controversy


Faisal Hussein lives in the West Bank and works in Israel. He's happy about the new bus service because it saves him money. (Photo by Joshua Mitnick.)

It’s 5:30 a.m. The sun has just started to come up.

Player utilities

Listen to the Story.

Hundreds of Palestinian men, wearing jackets and holding their lunches, are lined up in a parking lot. They’ve just come through an Israeli military checkpoint on the edge of the West Bank. They’re waiting to get on buses, for the last leg of their morning commute to work.

“No room, no room.” The driver said.

And he closed the doors as the last few men squeeze themselves into the aisle. These are West Bank Palestinians with work permits to enter Israel proper. They tend to be a little older — bread winners and family men — the kind of Palestinians that Israel considers less of a security threat.

Sitting in a window seat, a 36-year-old construction worker named Muhannad said this new bus is good.

"It’s only a $1.35 each way. It beats getting ripped off by gypsy van operators,” he said.

Muhannad said he hopes this service is here to stay. A grey-haired man named Azzem on his way to work in Tel Aviv agrees.

“Twenty-five shekels.” he said. “That’s what we’ve been getting charged. It’s criminal. That’s five times the cost of this bus trip by the way.”

Azzem said he would like to thank the Israeli company for providing a new service for Palestinian workers. He only wishes this bus could take him all the way home to his West Bank village, instead of dropping him off outside the checkpoint.

But the new bus line that’s effectively only for Palestinians also stirs feelings of resentment.

A man named Adl talked about riding the public bus from Tel Aviv in Israel to the large West Bank settlement of Ariel, not far from his village. Sometimes settlers would complain to the driver about Palestinians being on the bus, he said.

Adl said that one time he asked an Israeli man, why he was complaing.

"What have I done to you? We are both tired after a long day’s work and we both just want to go home," he recalled saying.

At the checkpoint, Adl said, the police took the Palestinians off the bus. And he could see the Israelis were happy to be rid of them. As he finished the story, several men also weighed in.

They said the new bus line was about racism, that it's humiliating to be put on separate bus lines.

For their part, Israeli officials say the new buses are not about forced segregation. Palestinians with work permits, they say, can ride on any bus they want. And for the public, some Israelis have a problem riding with Palestinians, others don’t, said 22-year-old university student Mirit. She was waiting for another bus in the West Bank settlement where she lives.

“I haven’t seen any problems with Israelis and Palestinians together on the bus, never,” she said. “The people are living here. They take their works. This is their country too. So, of course (I ride with them).”

Israeli human rights groups and some members of parliament say the bus service for Palestinian workers adds up to a policy of discrimination and racism. But Israeli peace activist Gershon Baskin said it’s not so simple.

“The reality is there is a poor economy next to a rich economy. The poor economy is providing workers to the rich economy. They have to move from point A to point B. There were too many workers under the current situation and the bus company saw an opportunity to make more money and added more bus lines,” Baskin said.

However, Baskin said the Palestinian-only buses do put a spotlight on the underlying problem. Israel continues to maintain a military occupation over the West Bank. And the two populations living there, Jewish settlers and Palestinian Arabs, do not have the same rights.

“There’s no such thing as separate and equal,” he said. “It didn’t work in America and it doesn’t work here. We’re living in a bi-national reality. We have been living in a bi-national reality where there are two separate economies and two separate legal systems and if that continues that becomes even more and more problematic.”

Baskin said the two sides could go a long way to solving the problem by reaching a political solution. Even after that though, Palestinian workers are likely to depend on the much larger Israeli economy — and maybe, some sort of bus service — for some time to come.