Most orange juice products made by Coke and other companies contain juice from Brazil, where the fungicide originated.
This week, The Food and Drug Administration said low levels of carbendazim had been found in shipments from Brazil, the world's largest producer of orange juice.
Carbendazim is banned in the US but still used in Brazil to treat black spot, a type of mold that grows on orange trees.
The FDA had said an unnamed juice company first alerted the agency to the problem about two weeks ago after testing its own and competitors' products.
It said the low levels are not a safety risk but the scare does have the public concerned and is affecting global orange juice prices.
On Wall Street, Coca-Cola stock fell about one percent on the news in afternoon trading but recouped its losses by the close of the bell.
Industry experts are also keeping an eye on PepsiCo Inc., which makes Tropicana and Dole. The two companies together hold almost a two-thirds of the American orange juice market.
More from GlobalPost: Orange juice prices hit record high