Turks outraged over French passage of genocide law
A new bill in France makes it a crime to deny genocide in France. The Turkish government is outraged because the law also makes it a crime to deny that the Ottoman Turks massacred millions of Armenians during World War I.
Turkey’s Prime Minister reacted angrily on Tuesday to a bill passed late Monday by the French Senate that would make it a crime to deny that Turks committed genocide against Armenians during the World War I.
The legislation includes penalties of up to one year in prison — and a fine of more than $50,000 — for anyone in France found guilty of denying a “recognized genocide.” It doesn’t mention the Turks or Armenians by name, but in 2001, the French government officially determined the death of more than one million Armenians was genocide.
Turkey has long maintained that the actual number of those killed was much lower, and that the deaths came in the course of war time. It’s a crime in Turkey to refer to those deaths as genocide.
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, speaking before Turkey’s parliament, condemned the French vote.
“This is the awakening of the values of the Middle Ages, which totally undermines European values and common sense,” Erdogan said. “You can’t judge or rewrite history in parliaments.”
The French Senate’s approval of the measure came after a lengthy debate. Armenia’s foreign minister, Edward Nalbandian, applauded the vote.
“This day will be written in gold not only in the history of friendship between the Armenian and French peoples, but also in the annals of the history of the protection of human rights worldwide,” Nalbandian said. “France reaffirmed its pivotal role as a genuine defender of universal human values.”
The vote puts French President Nicolas Sarkozy in a tricky spot. A deputy from his own party originally sponsored the bill. Sarkozy is facing re-election this year, and some have accused him of using the genocide legislation to court electoral favor with the nearly 600,000 people of Armenian descent living in France.
But there are also wider implications for France’s position in Europe and beyond. Sarkozy’s own foreign minister, Alain Juppe, opposed the bill.
“I think this initiative is untimely,” Juppe said. “What I would like to do today is to call on our Turkish friends to keep a cool head. Turkey is a big economic power, and we need to have good relations with it.”
France is Turkey’s fifth largest export market. The two countries do more than $13 billion in trade a year.
Now, Turkey is threatening a host of military, political and economic sanctions. Turkey’s ambassador to France said today that he expected to be recalled. A spokesman for the Turkish embassy in Paris said that “relations in every field have been stopped for the moment.”
But even before the passage of the genocide legislation, there was some friction between France and Turkey. President Sarkozy has been lukewarm, at best, when it comes to Turkey’s bid to join the European Union.
Soli Özel, a columnist with the Turkish newspaper Haber Turk, said it seemed Sarkozy is not especially concerned about having good relations with Turkey.
“In the Mediterranean, France considers Turkey a rival power, and would like to cut it down to size. That’s how it’s seen in Turkey anyway,” Özel said.
Turkish officials have said they would lobby to have France’s constitutional court rule on the genocide legislation. They’ve also said they wouldn’t impose any sanctions until Sarkozy signs the bill into law. Sarkozy’s office said on Tuesday that that would happen within two weeks.
"PRI's "The World" is a one-hour, weekday radio news magazine offering a mix of news, features, interviews, and music from around the globe. "The World" is a co-production of the BBC World Service, PRI and WGBH Boston. More about The World.