Germans angered over Catholic Church's decision to deny sacraments for church tax scofflaws
Germany has long required people who are members of a church or a synagogue to pay a tax that supports the church and its operations. But as more Catholics decline to pay, the church is telling them if they don't pay, they won't be allowed to receive church sacraments.
Germany levies a tax on anyone officially affiliated with a Christian church or a Jewish synagogue — an extra eight percent of what you pay in yearly income tax.
In recent years, more and more Catholics have been refusing to pay it. But last week, Germany’s Catholic Bishops said no more. If you don’t pay the tax, you don’t receive communion and other religious services.
A German court just ruled the church was within its rights to say no.
In the town of Dachau, some 20 minutes outside Munich, there’s an old, well-tended Catholic graveyard on a hill. If you want to be buried there, with a priest presiding and praying for your soul, but you haven’t paid your church tax — forget it. Same goes for having your kids baptized or even receiving communion.
In short, you have to pay to pray, according to a decree issued last week by Germany’s Catholic bishops.
You’re not excommunicated, you stay a member of the Catholic community. But you lose certain rights, said Gilinde Koebl-Stecher. She’s an official at the Catholic Diocese in downtown Munich, one of the country’s largest.
“The meaning of the church that solidarity is shown if you pay your church tax. And in the law it is written that the member of the church is obliged to pay a contribution,” Koeble-Stecher said.
Germany’s church tax was set up to compensate religious institutions after most of their lands were confiscated in 1803. But a growing number of religious activists are taking issue with the tax. Among them is Christian Weisner, a resident of Dachau, with a group called We Are Church. He said church membership is based on faith, not on a financial contract.
“I think in Germany we have a special situation in that you can only be a Catholic when you are paying church tax. But that is theologically wrong,” Weisner said. “If a person is baptized once, he is Catholic and he or she will be a Catholic all life long.”
Germany’s Catholic church has been losing more than 100,000 members a year for decades now, as parishioners get turned off by sex abuse scandals and the church’s conservative positions on issues like abortion and women priests. Weisner said Catholic officials should focus their energy on soul-searching, not on sending threatening missives to people who refuse to pay the tax.
“I think the bishops should ask why are you leaving, and what can we do for you? But now they are sending that letter, that said you can’t be a godfather and godmother anymore, you can’t have a church wedding. And I think this is a threatening message to people,” he said.
But threatening may just be what the church is after. Among the multitudes abandoning the church, some are simply protesting the tax, yet still attending mass, going to confession and otherwise participating in the church. It’s a tax dodge, church officials say, and it ends up hurting society’s poorest.
On one of Munich’s busiest squares, stands a small, wood-sided mobile home called the Island. It’s a rapid response center for people in crisis, funded through the church-tax. Social worker Wolfgang Tutsch said counselors receive about 8,000 people a year, helping them through marriage, money problems and more.
“We want to be very near to the people and their problems,” he said. “So, to reduce the borders. They just should be on the way and say, I feel totally bad, and there’s a door I can go in and there is a little island to find a little bit of help.”
But good works aside, some members of the church itself say the latest plan to withhold sacraments from tax objectors could backfire.
The parish of Benedictine Monk Pater Korbinian runs a soup kitchen for the homeless. The project doesn’t use money from the church tax. The Benedictines have a brewery and beer sales keep the soup kitchen open.
Korbinian said he thinks the new tax enforcement policy is going to drive even more people from the church. He said he likes Italy’s system, and Spain’s, where everyone pays a much smaller annual tax. But you get to choose where the money goes: to a church or to some other social cause.
“And I think it would be much fairer. You know, the church in Germany is really rich. Our archdiocese has more employees than the Holy See. I think much more than a thousand work directly for the diocese,” Korbinian said.
Over at the diocese, Koebl-Stecher confirmed that the church’s finances are sound.
“I think we are not struggling. We are doing well,” she said.
But she insisted the church is not lining its pockets with the religious tax, but using it to pay for its churches and programs.
But Weisner said his group isn’t giving up. They’re taking their demands to Rome next week to mark the 50th anniversary of the last major Roman Catholic reform: Vatican 2.
"PRI's "The World" is a one-hour, weekday radio news magazine offering a mix of news, features, interviews, and music from around the globe. "The World" is a co-production of the BBC World Service, PRI and WGBH Boston. More about The World.