Despite law, some new Americans may not get voting support they need
Under the Voting Rights Act, any legal jurisdiction with at least 5 percent of its population speaking something other than English as a foreign language must provide ballots and voting support in that language, as well as English. But, whether intentionally or inadvertently, many jurisdictions are ignoring that requirement.
When Americans go to the polls come November, millions will be voting in languages other than English.
Voting jurisdictions are required by law to provide bilingual ballots and language assistance when 5 percent of the population does not “understand English adequately enough to participate in the electoral process.”
That’s been the law since 1975.
But many counties and states don’t comply. And when the topic came up at a Republican presidential debate in January, Mitt Romney spoke against bilingual ballots.
Losing access to a bilingual ballot could harm people like Philip Van, a political refugee from Vietnam who moved to California in 1979. Van grew up speaking Chinese and Vietnamese. Six years after he arrived here, Van had to demonstrate some English proficiency to become an American citizen. But learning English as an adult, then voting in this new language wasn’t so easy.
Sure, he could easily choose between two candidates, but deciphering propositions and bond measures, that was tough.
"I have to take a lot of time to read (the ballot). And then I check with people, where we need to understand more clearly, what is good and what is bad," he said.
Van says many new Americans are afraid to vote in English, afraid they’ll make a mistake. Van lives in San Francisco, which now offers ballots in English, Chinese and Spanish. Van says its easier for him to vote now.
"A lot of people, even though they are well-educated, they are engineers, they are doctors, but for new immigrants, maybe they don’t quite understand about the political stuff," he said.
When multilingual ballots are offered, more people vote. Eight years ago, San Diego County began providing voting assistance in Vietnamese.
The results were immediate and dramatic.
“Voter registration for the Vietnamese community increased by 30 percent,” said Carlo De La Cruz with the Asian Law Caucus in San Francisco.
De La Cruz said bilingual ballots are crucial today as the U.S. becomes more diverse. Nationwide, one-in-three Asian Americans struggles with English.
“That means that over 30 percent of our population needs some kind of assistance when it comes to being able to navigate our democracy and the political system,” De La Cruz said.
The Moral vs. The Legal
But not everybody thinks American voters should get assistance. At a Republican primary debate this past January in Florida, Newt Gingrich said ballots should only be in English.
“I think Speaker Gingrich is right,” he said. “Look, English is the language of this nation. People need to learn English to be able to be successful, to get great jobs. We don`t want to have people limited in their capacity to achieve the American dream because they don`t speak English.”
Six years ago, Congress reauthorized the language provision of the Voting Rights Act. A group of conservative Republicans mounted a campaign to stop it from happening. But the measure easily passed the Republican-led Congress and was signed into law by President George W. Bush.
Bruce Adelson — a former senior attorney with the Justice Department and now CEO of the company, Federal Compliance Consulting — said the ship has sailed.
“Whether you agree with it or not, whether you think every American citizen should speak English or not, those are very valid points," Adelson said. "The law is the law. This law has been tested, evaluated, challenged. It’s withstood all of them.”
The law might be the law, but that doesn’t mean all jurisdictions comply. In the past decade, the Justice Department has filed complaints against 35 cities and counties for violating election language provisions.
"These cases can be very expensive to litigate and to deal with," Adelson said. "And I always advise election officials, it’s much better to comply voluntarily, then to get the dreaded call, letter or email from the Department of Justice, from my old friends, saying essentially, 'we’re going to come to visit you because we think you’re violating federal law.'"
Problems with Compliance
Just across the bay from San Francisco, Alameda County violated the language provision of the Voting Rights Act last year. The county, which is home to the city of Oakland, has a large immigrant population and is required to provide language assistance in four languages: Spanish, Chinese, Vietnamese and Tagalog, the major language spoken in the Philippines.
County officials say they weren’t thumbing their noses at the law. Cynthia Cornejo, the Deputy Registrar for Alameda County, said the county was required to provide about 1,000 bilingual poll workers — again, in four languages — for the June primary.
"We assessed probably close to maybe 2,200 people, just to see if they could read, speak, write the language," she said. Then we had to do an enormous outreach effort, all the way almost until the week before the election, and try and hit our numbers. And then train them also."
In June, Alameda County again failed to meet their legal obligations for Chinese and Tagalog poll workers. Cornejo said they’re scrambling to cover 785 polling stations, and that’s not just for federal elections.
"Odd number years are no longer a lull, we could have anywhere from two to six elections on any given year," she said.
Groups like the Asian Law Caucus recognize the strains on Alameda County. But they’re not letting election officials off the hook just for trying.
“Potentially, it means the disenfranchisement of hundreds of thousands of voters within Alameda County,” De La Cruz said.
Across the nation, more than 240 jurisdictions in 25 states will also be required to provide voting assistance this November.
That covers 19 million Americans who could use help voting in a language other than English.
"PRI's "The World" is a one-hour, weekday radio news magazine offering a mix of news, features, interviews, and music from around the globe. "The World" is a co-production of the BBC World Service, PRI and WGBH Boston. More about The World.