Science, Tech & Environment

The protectors of the world's largest fresh water lake may be put out of business by a Russian court

Baikal boat.jpg

Credit:

Peter Thomson

A boat captain welcomes a passenger aboard in Zabaikalsky National Park, on the eastern shore of Siberia's Lake Baikal.

Siberia's Lake Baikal is the largest fresh water lake on the planet.

Player utilities

(This story is based on a radio interview. Listen to the full interview.)

Despite being far from most of civilization, Baikal faces a long list of environmental challenges.

But unlike many of the world's natural wonders, it doesn't have many organizations trying to protect it. Now, just about the only local voice for protecting Baikal is facing possible shutdown at the hands of the Russian government.

The World's environment editor Peter Thomson is the in-house expert on Lake Baikal and wrote the book "Sacred Sea: A Journey to Lake Baikal."

"Even if you don't pay much attention to what's going on in Russia these days you've probably heard that the government there has been putting a lot of pressure on independent citizens' groups," he said. "What folks in the west often call NGOs, or non-governmental organizations."

Last year, Russia adopted a law that requires any NGO that gets funding from outside the country and also engages in political activity to register as a "foreign agent."  In a place like Russia, with has a long history of distrust of outsiders, can be tantamount to being branded a spy.

It's taking a while for this law to ripple through Russian society, but a few weeks ago a court in Irkutsk ordered a local group called Baikal Environmental Wave to register as a foreign agent because, the court ruled, the group meets those two criteria — they get money from outside the country and they engage in political activity.

The group says it won't do that.

Thomson spoke with one of the group's two leaders, Jennie Sutton. She's a Brit who's lived near Lake Baikal for almost 40 years and is a Russian citizen. She told him Baikal Environmental Wave won't register for a couple of very plain reasons.

"'First and foremost,' she told me, 'registering would be a lie. Secondly, it would destroy one's image with the general public,'" Thomson said.

Being called a foreign agent in Russia can put one in an untenable, if not outright dangerous, position.

"And of course Baikal Wave isn't working as a front for anyone," Thomson said. "They're local folks working to protect this lake, which is really among the most amazing places on earth."

It's the oldest and deepest lake on earth — more than a mile deep. It's also the largest lake in the world by volume — with roughly the same amount of water as all of North America's Great Lakes combined.

It also has some of the purest water you'll find anywhere on the planet.

"Because it's so old and so big, it's home to more than a thousand animals and plants that exist nowhere else, including the world's only species of fresh water seals," Thomson said.

All that earned it a spot on the UN's list of World Heritage Sites.

"It's also just incredibly beautiful," he added.

There are two big issues facing Lake Baikal that Baikal Wave has been able to help defeat. One was a huge oil pipeline that would've gone through the watershed and very close to the lake itself. After a lot of pressure from Baikal Wave and others, a few years back, it was rerouted.

The second issue is a paper mill right on the shore of the lake that has been dumping PCBs and other pollutants into Baikal for decades. The wave was involved in a long and torturous fight to close that factory ... and after a lot of back and forth it does seem to have shut down just this year.

Of course there are still more threats. Among them are mining in the lake's watershed, Illegal logging, pollution from tourism and second home development around the lake is a big one.

"While there are strong laws on the books about protecting Baikal, they're largely ignored," Thomson said.

But Baikal Environmental Wave is up against the wall. The short story is, without outside funding, the group has no hope.

"There is no tradition in Russia of public support for NGOs. Even Greenpeace, that has a whole group of people working on raising money, can only raise something like ten or 12 percent of its budget," Sutton said.

Sutton said her group is going to appeal the court ruling, but that they expect they'll probably lose.

"Ultimately, they'll probably be faced with big fines that they just won't be able to pay, and so they'll have to close," Thomson said.

If that happens, then at least for now, Baikal will be left without any significant domestic citizens group fighting for its protection.

  • BPPP.JPG

    Credit:

    James Thomson

    The Baikalsk Pulp and Paper Mill, built in the 1960s on the southern shore of Lake Baikal, released millions of tons of polluted water into the lake before it finally closed earlier this year.

  • Karte_baikal2.png

    Credit:

    Wikimedia Commons

    A German map of Lake Baikal. The environmental group Baikal Environmental Wave is based in Irkutsk, the largest city in the region.

  • NASA1.jpg

    Credit:

    NASA

    Lake Baikal is a favorite target of orbiting photographers. This shot was taken by an astronaut on a US space shuttle mission. The lake, which contains as much fresh water as all of the North American Great Lakes combined, lies in an extremely deep rift valley in Central Siberia.

  • Sutton.jpg

    Credit:

    Peter Thomson

    Jennie Sutton is a transplanted British subject who's made her home in Irkutsk, near Lake Baikal, for nearly 40 years, and is now co-director of the environmental group Baikal Environmental Wave. BEW may be forced to close after a court found it was a "foreign agent" under a new Russian law tightly regulating NGOs.

  • Omul+ copy.jpg

    Credit:

    USSR Ministry of Communication

    Baikal is famous locally for its plentiful fish, like the omul, as well as more that 1,000 other species of plants and animals that are unique to the lake.

  • Bolshie Koty.JPG

    Credit:

    James Thomson

    The village of Bolshie Koty is one a just a few settlements on the steep shores of Lake Baikal. Bolshie Koty is home to two small research institutes exploring the unique ecology of the world's deepest lake.

Comments